Asked my wife to listen to my main three guitars I am playing now. I told her to rank them according to which was the most pleasing to her ears. What do you think was her order? The first guitar is a 1967 J-45, (my high school guitar by the way), 1993 Gibson Centennial 1939 J100, 2009 Legacy TOB Vintage.

I would never ask my wife to rate my guitars--she's about some kind of tone deaf. And besides, I got an onery one and if she could tell one from another, she would sure as hell tell me the one I didn't like. Ah, 43 years and going strong. By the way, she bought me my first Cargo--she may be tone deaf, but she knows what I like, and once in a while she gives it to me. I'm blessed.
She ranked them
1. J-45
2. Legacy
3. J-100
Which shows two things. One, a carbon in the middle of this pack is not bad, he loves wood guitars. Second, I have made no progress inproving my herd since high school.
Steve
And 3, when you find what you like, you stick with it. I'd say you have a pretty nice herd. And a pretty good woman, too.
What Evan said.
She is a keeper, I met her playing that J-45 so maybe that influenced her beyond the carbon. Known the J-45 only a few years longer than her. Better keep them both.
Steve
A marriage is sort of like owning a wood guitar ... if you don't consistently "tweak it", it won't stay in tune!!
(Or the obverse, if you just leave it alone it goes flat.)
But I'm a nooby --- only been married 37 yrs. She's willing to listen to me practice/play and bought me my D-35 when I was without a guitar a couple of years ago -- that's the one she chose, folllowed by the RainSong and CA-OX (although she "likes" all three).
Ray
My wife loves the sound of my Steel Rider. I figure it's the open/stereo sound that comes from the dual sound ports.
I would say that my ex-wife would rank my guitars right below me, which is definitely saying something. .. . .
d_e
Well, at least you were not at the bottom of the ranking.
Did she peek? I'll bet she picked the carbon fiber. Got you right around her little finger.
Evan